The title of this article is derived from a question which children ask each other to sassily test the mental clumsiness of the person they are talking to. I am not sure if kids still do it to this day, but it was popular when I was a kid myself…perhaps things were simpler back then (this very, very complaint-sounding statement is a sign I am aging… 😱).
Let me pursue my intended analogy: consider someone who collects straw threads by hand and fits them into a backpack of standard capacity, say around ~20 liters. The collector can distribute the weight of the straw pretty evenly between his shoulders and, so, support it with all of his back and abdominal muscles.
The growing amount of straw being forced into the backpack catches the eye pretty early on, because it occupies very much volume. Barring a compression process with a professional farmer’s mechanical tools, the total weight you can fit into the backpack by hand will barely exceed 7, 10 kilograms tops.
Therefore, when the backpack is finally full and taken away from the carrier’s shoulders, the amount of work performed is clearly visible.
Consider now a person collecting balls of lead. One kilogram of lead easily fits into a round sphere with a diameter of less than 3 centimeters. It looks like it does not occupy almost any volume. To the eyes of the person who has never carried lead and is used to measure weight through the volume-weight correspondence he has trained his senses on by dint of looking at straw, it looks like lead weighs absolutely nothing!
If you collect lead spheres, after 10 of them, which will hardly occupy the full bottom of your backpack, you will be pretty much done and will walk away with a backpack appearing pretty “empty“.
And, by the way, since the weight is concentrated on the bottom of the backpack, carrying it to the final destination will be much more uncomfortable, for your back, then carrying the equivalent amount of straw. Plus, if you are not a fool, you know that dropping straw is relatively harmless, whereas dropping lead spheres can lead to a lot of trouble.
Churning out volumes vs. thinking obsessively.
The lazy lose to the average.
Farnam street weekly newsletter,
The average lose to the focused.
The focused lose to the obsessed.
november 17th 2024
Back when I was 11 years old and later on until I grew 28 and left Italy for Poland, I worked as an employee at Dentoni every summer of my life. My father would direct me to fill the roles of bartender, waiter, clerk, cashier and so on, depending on his personnel needs. I would comply quite lightheartedly, for I liked feeling useful and earning money.
But when my time was done -and it was often a 12 hours shift or more in the summer- I would feel completely free again and go out doing whatever I had set out to do in my free time: dating someone, going out with friends, reading books (something I have stayed addicted to…) and so on.
This is, more or less, what I am by analogy referring to by “carrying straw”: you can measure your work in real time by logging the volumes you churn out. It applies neatly to blue collar employees’ work, for you can easily track how many customers they serve, how many coffee cups they make in a shift, how many tables they deliver orders to. And, by the way, a necessary disclaimer: I have enormous respect for their role. The purpose of this post is to illustrate the perspective of the minority on the other side w.r.t. them.
Now compare this to my present situation: I serve customers on Sundays, holidays and during the summer; plus, when it is really needed due to lack of personnel. That’s it. But for most of the rest of the time I am in my office or, even if not there, I am constantly thinking about my company. I do not think about it in the sense that I am drafting strategies every waking moment of mine, but still I do feel the weight of my responsibility reverberate in my mind most of the time.
This is very much similar to the situation my father was in before me. I remember him saying to me once, shortly before dying: this is a company with a yearly turnover of X millions (the interested reader can look up the public P&L), so you’ve got to think about it from the early morning until you go to bed in the evening.
Even after conceding that he was managing his time less effectively then I am, considering my sharing responsibilities with my cousin, he was, by and large, right. For even after delegating half of his daily chores to my cousin and taking over the other half, the ghost-sensation -so to speak- of the weight I have to carry is still ever-present on my shoulders. The feeling does not go away once I drop the physical backpack, i.e. after I leave our venue.
This is what I am referring to by analogy when I talk about carrying 10 kilograms of lead: it is not visible, but it weights on you incessantly even after the backpack is dropped, because it is uncomfortable and, if dropped, it causes a lot of damage.
Linear vs nonlinear consequentiality
I attended a great high school, Liceo Classico Palmieri. I had to binge-study Latin and Greek and I am proud of the knowledge and discipline stock I came out of it with. I also carried out of it a cognitive dissonance w.r.t. the entrepreneurial environment I was raised in. Palmieri has historically been a den of left-wings, who were fond of Marxist and Platonic ideas. They had’t confronted the reality of a P&L their whole life, to be sure. But I was consciously being taught Plato and Marx, not microeconomics, though I was less consciously eating and studying literature and philosophy classics thanks to the latter.
So, if you had asked me, right out of school, why an entrepreneur is earning so much more money than his employees, I would have pointed out how hard my father, uncle, mother and aunt have worked for so many years to build what they have, if forced to; if not forced to answer, I would have shunned entering the debate, for I knew I would then be confronted with such statements as “what could they have done without the people they surely underpaid?”.
Such statements would irritate me, for I knew for a fact that people were working a lot with us, but they were generally happy about their salaries. But I could not prove this in conversations with presumed philosophers and “workers activists”, especially with those who had never worked one single day in their lives yet, a group which included self-declared “well-read” and “knowledgeable” fellow classmates.
There is an innate tendency in human beings to mimic and adapt to the environment they are in. So, if you are the son of successful craftsmen and/or entrepreneurs in the middle of blue collar families’ children frowning upon you, you would rather try to avoid such discussions then think deeply about a poignant reply.
I went along with the feeling that the courage to start a company and the implied stress (then vaguely defined for me, who had not experimented it personally yet) justified the profits, after acknowledging the role of a minimal but necessary dose of luck. It never downed upon me, statistics-deprived as I was, that, while the average salary of an employee is clearly visible because it is publicly displayed on pay slips, the average profitability of an entrepreneur is less so; first, making sense of a P&L is much harder than looking at the bold entry on the bottom line of a pay slip displaying an employee’s in-pocket salary; second and more importantly, although successful entrepreneurs are those catching the public eye, a proper average of their yearly profits should include the often null and more often negative logs of those who fail and go bankrupt, which would instill a better feeling of what enterprise risk is.
Beside that, an even more convincing argument came to the rescue much later on.
Enter the Austrians…
My first exposure to the ideas of Austrian economics came a couple of years ago through Mark Spitznagel’s great book The Dao of Capital. The originator of the school was Carl Menger, tutor to prince Rudolph of Austria and Hungary and mentor of the great Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk. And Böhm-Bawerk had it nicely cut with an argument based on the temporal asymmetry of the entrepreneur and employee’s situation. I have never read the original version, but here is my Spitznagel-mediated understanding.
Suppose that you do not accept the current market price for the hourly work of an employee, which the business owner is paying fully, because you do not believe in markets and you deem it insufficient; suppose that you do not understand that bearing the risk of running an enterprise with your own capital entitles the entrepreneur to a cut of the profits greater than any of his non risk-bearing employees either. Assuming this is not enough for you to accept the successful entrepreneur’s profitability, then we must agree on this: if the employee’s work is really so equally fundamental that he should take a cut of the profits comparable to the entrepreneur’s, then he should be ready to give back all of his (upward adjusted) monthly salaries of any given year if, eventually, the company goes bankrupt in that year.
This skin-in-the-game argument based on the temporal asymmetry between the employee’s compensation and the entrepreneur’s eventual profitability makes the difference in their situations tangible and understandable even for the layman. That’s why I love it and why, looking at my father’s grave, I regret understanding all of this after he is already gone.
Nowadays, I like framing the discussion in different terms, as a contrast among linear and non-linear payoffs. A picture is worth a thousand words, so I will allow myself to post one a plot of an employee’s compensation growth over the course of a year and two among many of an entrepreneur’s possible profit paths over the same year, both in the case it is a good year (green) and in the case it is a disaster (red).

As I have said early on in this post, I have long been in my employees’ shoes and I often return there to this day. I have tremendous respect for their role and importance, as I have discussed elsewhere in this blog. This is not the point of this article. In fact, this is meant to be addressed mainly to people claiming that entrepreneurs (at least those who pay fair wages, as I undoubtedly know that we do at Dentoni’s) prosper at the expense of their employees.
And for all the employees out there who share such dissatisfaction with their situation, assuming as a necessary condition that they are being paid a fair market salary, I shall invite them , in case they aspire to more: join the circus above and point on landing on a green slot every year of your entrepreneurial life. My wish for you to be successful wish is totally sincere.
You will discover that you’ll soon join me in (some) sleepless nights and incessant background worries about your company. You will be carrying 10 kilograms of lead while you watch those on your payroll churning out straw backpacks. This is the price you pay for betting on the green outcome and avoiding the red one.
Understanding nonlinearities has added a great deal of depth to my thought processes about the world. I hope it can be a source of inspiration for the reader of this post as well.
Mirko Serino





