Spedizione Gratuita per ordine minimo di €95
English

The HR problem in the context of Covid-19 (and of the decline of the Western global leadership).

dalio-CWH

This morning, a respected acquaintance of mine recommended on LinkedIn (somewhat the equivalent of a “Like” on Facebook, for those unfamiliar) an interesting article about the changing job market for young people, particularly those highly qualified between the ages of 26 and 35, based on a statistical study by the Italian Association for Employees Management. It reveals that a very significant portion of the young people interviewed have left or plan to leave their jobs, especially in companies in Northern Italy and particularly in the marketing, IT, and production sectors, thus in fields that require a high level of professional specialization.
Further exploration reveals that 20% are fleeing from “a negative work environment within the company”, a variable—speaking from experience—that is very vague but understandable in broad terms, while 25% are seeking “a new sense of life”.

Since I am trained as a physicist and I know well that data, by themselves, are just meaningless numbers and that, to acquire meaning, they require a considerable and significant effort of interpretation, I take the liberty to dedicate the space of March on this blog to reflections complementary to the article itself. As the owner of a company that offers work

  1. predominantly seasonal
  2. in a sector different from those emphasized in the article
  3. often aimed at very young, inexperienced individuals, less qualified than the professionals focused on in the cited article
  4. in Southern Italy, rather than the North,

they can provide a snapshot of a population segment which is young but deeply different, in culture and age, from the segment on which the said article focuses.

Why am I keen to spend words on this? Allow me an analogy: think of the face of a person crying out of despair… perhaps, in some cases, doesn’t it resemble the expression of someone crying out of happiness? Intense pain and extreme pleasure are hard to distinguish if one only has a partial view of the situation…

The purpose of these considerations, then, will be to offer a glimpse into another sector of the youth employment world, to which parts of the youth population belong that, continuing with the above analogy, we can define as “lower”, in the specific and strictly non-discriminatory sense of being less professionally qualified, for reasons that are simply age-related…perhaps it could help us understand whether we are enjoying ourselves or if we are being skinned alive. Probably, to anticipate my point of view that I will develop at the end of the article, we are witnessing a mix of both, due to specific historical and social reasons of which we perhaps do not even understand the extent, being too hypnotized by the novelty of the phenomenon to seriously reflect on its causes.

I must first state plainly and publicly, and I am proud to say this, that our company can fully boast of absolute punctuality in payments and a complete absence of undeclared work for all our seasonal employees (including the very common practice of part-time contracts where a person ends up working full-time, which we do not practice), as well as high organization and structuring of work shifts, during which, in full summer operation, we employ 50 people alongside 7 owners who actively participate in the production and sales activities, in addition to offering salaries higher than the average market rate.
That said, the tendencies I observe in the wake of the pandemic, especially last year, are

  1. dramatic lowering of the feminine component of our employees base;
  2. lowering of the Italian component of our employees base, slowly but surely taken over by extra-Eu workers, particularly from Senegal and India;
  3. dramatically lower share of the very young (16-25 years old) among new employees drafts.

These are trends that have been in place for years, which I remember my father already talking about, but the pandemic and the measures taken to counteract its economic effects have undoubtedly accelerated them, as the difference between 2021 and the previous two years has been abyssal. Even in the United States, which adopted similar social support measures, equally unhappy trends have been recorded in seasonal activities. However, a common problem doesn’t always mean half the joy, in my view.

Moreover, the fact that the “leader” country of the former Western democracies and the greatest advocate of work as the ultimate sense of life is going through a similar crisis among the very young, who are not yet old enough to be absorbed by the large corporations, prime evangelists of work as the ultimate reason for life, makes us wonder even more if the problem might be something else, even there. Namely: is it possible that, where in the West a bit too much emphasis has been placed on support subsidies for non-workers—perhaps simply not stopping them promptly—this has instilled, in the minds of people born in the last 20 years, an overly welfare-centered view of life just at the age when these people should be confronting the reality of earning their own independence, assuming we want these individuals to become responsible adults?

It’s needless to specify that I have thrown out a bit of a too-general provocation, making a broad generalization myself, but not unlike those who group under “search for a new sense of life” the 25% of the exoduses from the workplace mentioned above… the majority of these people are not going to meditate in an Indian ashram or a Tibetan monastery to free themselves from ego; rather, they are looking for a job that requires less daily commitment or a higher salary for the same effort, as candidly written by the authors of the two pieces above; as I have already written, I suspend judgment on the people in the first category, because the meaning of the statement should be evaluated on a case-by-case basis, while if those in the second group were labeled this way, I would frankly smile bitterly.

I distinctly remember when I was a child, and during the summer seasons, I was an apprentice myself to this or that employee of ours (yes, today I am the CEO of Dentoni, but I worked for years under the guidance of our employees and I am very proud of it). The bar was crowded with boys and girls just a few years older than me who, in a short time and under the guidance of more experienced colleagues, learned the basics of the roles of sales clerk or bartender and then faced a long and very hard summer season – back then, there wasn’t even a day off – without anyone worrying that they would leave due to a reprimand from an older colleague or after facing a harder day’s work, as still happens systematically with us on summer weekends and for most of August. Many of them later graduated, others joined the military, others specialized in the catering sector: none of them ever came out traumatized, in any case. In fact, there was a camaraderie and, at times, a joviality quite different from what is the order of the day now, when, with a bitter smile, I increasingly have to bid farewell to people on trial or who have only had an interview, for the most varied and hilarious reasons…

  • “My father doesn’t agree with me coming home at 2 in the morning”; yet the beer gardens and dance clubs are full of kids his age, obviously of legal age, until that time and later, but ok…
  • “I can’t do the mid-day (mid-morning to late afternoon) shift, it takes up my whole day”; actually, the person would earn €1,100 net per month (plus social security contributions) already in their first job experience, with a day off in July, and an extra paid day of work per week in August, obviously being able to wake up leisurely and go out in the evenings all summer long. So much for theft, but ok…
  • “Can’t I ever be free on Saturdays or Sundays?”; I won’t even comment on this, but it was really asked of me…


And there would still be an endless variety of variations on the theme, among which the most amusing (or depressing) come from pseudo-“little men” who say they are enthusiastic about my proposals in the initial interview, only to retract via WhatsApp the day before the trial… evidently, the influence of the family does not go in the direction of encouraging a young man to learn a job and earn something with his own sacrifice. Evidently, we do not realize how much understanding and respect for others comes from having experienced, at least once in one’s life, manual labor, perhaps just for the duration of a few summers, even when one ends up working as office employees, teachers, professionals, and so forth. It is in this line that the already mentioned constant increase in the percentage of foreigners, almost 100% non-EU, in our workforce and others fits.

I am talking, of course, about collective considerations that matter little to the average contemporary parent, focused exclusively on protecting their children, but this is, after all, the essence of the drama that we fatalistically and improperly—in the social case—call “destiny”: increasingly similar individual choices oriented towards the immediate advantage of the individual, which end up crushing the values of the community in the medium-long term… to the detriment of social cohesion, which is based on respect and understanding of others, which is not acquired by grace received at school, whatever is said.

There is no trick and no deception, because these are films already shown elsewhere: we have taken the road already traveled by the Anglo-Saxon society “well,” particularly in the London area, where, in catering and manual work in general, young English people from the middle and upper-middle bourgeoisie are almost not even found at a high price: not for nothing the division of their society into well-defined classes has been an accepted fact for some time.

Now that I have given voice to my experience and my perspective for the future, I only have to clarify my overall point of view: I frankly agree that the Western model of obsessive work culture is not healthy. Many companies, especially in sectors most affected by smart working during the pandemic, have been forced to realize this and are taking steps in this regard, including experimenting with a four-day work week.

Personally, I believe that the long-term cure for this illness comes from scaling down what David Graeber, the late British anarchist sociologist, called bullshit jobs, namely that set of professions that add nothing useful to society but nonetheless keep hundreds of thousands of people occupied… technology could allow everyone to work less and better, but in reality, we have invented a lot of jobs and professions that seemingly only serve to keep us busy. In this, there is a point for those who can no longer stand the straitjacket of so many monotonous and useless jobs so widespread in our society.

On the other hand, the direction taken by millennials, i.e., people born from 2000 onwards, is not at all a remedy to this situation, but is indeed much worse than the problem itself. The mix of living with overprotective parents, obsessed with the mirage of white-collar jobs (non-manual, non-worker type), too often taken for granted, leads young people to increasingly refuse first jobs that would be very formative, especially in areas like catering, where something real is produced for the end consumer and where one experiences work both from a physical point of view and in terms of team spirit, experiences that constitute a not insignificant baggage in life, even when and if one ends up performing a completely different and more suited profession to our tendencies.

The question that comes too easily, of course, is: can we oppose this drift?
An individual clearly cannot do anything, nor do I write this blog to propagate my vision, but simply to bear witness to what I see happening, framing it according to my perspective. I just hope that at least one or two people, reading these reflections, are encouraged to reflect similarly, perhaps constructively disavowing what I write.


Finally, this is certainly not a blog of history or geopolitics, but it is a fact that the decline of societies that constitute the beacon of all the great empires of the past occurs simultaneously with the disaffection towards productivity and the sacrifice of their ruling class, as well as with the excessive accumulation of debt by the dominant power. We in Europe are certainly not the leaders of the empire that guides the world, we are only its main vassals, as well as its principal bridgehead in Eurasia. Globalization has led both us and the USA to a drastic downsizing of our working class and the values it embodied, having delegated the majority of productive activities to developing countries, to save on labor costs. This is what we see reflected in the attitude of the very young, unfortunately encouraged by families, which feed a vicious circle of loss of the culture of productivity. The Covid-19 phenomenon has only been a catalyst for this, causing a worrying acceleration, for those who can observe it from the position in which people like us find ourselves.
In the West, this trend has coincided, without being the sole cause, with the accumulation of monstrous debt, when compared to GDP and compared to countries on which we depend for primary goods like agricultural fertilizers, gas, grain… and whose precise names I will not mention, in these times of stupid sanction hostility and self-harm.
Finally, even this last phenomenon of reinforcing our armies, as well as the debt and the loss of the culture of productivity and savings, are all signs of a decline that only very difficult and controversial political decisions may, perhaps, delay beyond the temporal horizon of our lives, assuming that there is still someone capable of understanding that the Cold War logic first and unipolarism then, characteristic of the 20th century, should no longer belong to us.

Let me close with this remark: are we really in search of “ua new meaning of life” or are we just running away from staring in the face of our civilization’s demise and eecline?

Mirko Serino e Franz Panarese

P.S. if any readers of the present article were interested in disproving its theses, they could click here.

Lascia un Commento

Il tuo indirizzo email non sarà pubblicato. I campi obbligatori sono contrassegnati *

Select the fields to be shown. Others will be hidden. Drag and drop to rearrange the order.
  • Foto
  • Codice Prodotto
  • Prezzo
  • Aggiungi al carrello
Clicca fuori per uscire dalla comparazione
Compara